Batavia Nervosa Diagnosis
If you've ever had to live in close proximity with someone who is simultaneously obsessive and borderline-psychotic at any perceived offense - then you will recoil in recognition at the story of Charles Martin, a 67-year-old man who shot a 15 year old boy to death for walking on his lawn. Prior to the killing he tracked every interaction with the neighbors he despised in a small pocket diary, which was made available in court. A sample:
Oct. 1, 2003: For the last 3 to 4 weeks, I have been getting a much larger amount of grass on my driveway after Larry (Mugrage) cuts their grass. After watching closer, I found Larry was (mowing) the grass on my property along the road. I measured a length of 14 feet today past their (property) line. I asked Larry why. He said he must be going crazy. After I showed him the difference between (how) our mowers cut, he said he had not cut that far. He also told me he hadn't used the push mower last week. Another lie.There's no excusing Martin's actions, no mitigating factor that should cause his sentencing to be less than any other capital offense. Still, it's made more difficult by the fact that the 15-year-old, on the day of the murder, decided to exacerbate the situation by calling Martin names. It's exactly the type of thing any teenager might do, especially with friends nearby.
Oct. 21, 2003: Little Larry is cutting the grass as they were cutting the strip between our property line. He and his mother were talking very loudly and shaking their heads as they (looked) over at me on my back porch. They were acting as if I had done something to their property. After they were done, I went out and looked at the property lines. I have not cut on their property. Anita is watching two girls and a boy after school from 3:15 p.m. to 5:15 p.m. This whole thing could be a ploy for the kids to be able to come into my yard. Their behavior makes very little sense to me.
Once I had a neighbor like this, and I was lucky enough to have somebody point out that the behaviors were off the chart of normal because of mental illness. Once you understand you cannot handle the situation the same way as any other social relationship, because almost every action will feed into the hostility complex, and be calculated into their paranoid narrative. Eventually it may become a legal matter, but until then the only recourse is unflinching, stoic detachment. (Not a bad philosophy in many instances, I've discovered.)
In the Martin case the signs may have been too subtle. And the standard of accountability remains the same, regardless. But it's hard not to imagine how the confrontation could have gone differently when you consider the family's grief.